cdmagurus.com
10-11-2016, 04:30 PM
The justices of the U.S. Supreme Court,-hearing arguments in a long-running Apple and Samsung patent dispute on Tuesday, seemed to question a 19th-century law that allows huge infringement damages in design patent cases.
Questioning lawyers for the two companies, the justices repeatedly referred to a law (http://www.scotusblog.com/2016/10/argument-preview-justices-to-consider-billion-dollar-verdict-for-samsungs-infringement-of-the-design-of-apples-iphone/) that instructs courts to award patent damages based on the total profit from the infringing device, instead of from just the infringing pieces of the device.
The total-profit rule-for design patents may work for simple products, but not for complex ones like smartphones, Justice Stephen Breyer said. "For wallpaper, you get the whole thing," he said, according to Fortune.com (http://fortune.com/2016/10/11/apple-samsung-scotus/). "A Rolls-Royce with the thing on the hood? No, no, no you don’t get profits on the whole car."
To read this article in full or to leave a comment, please click here (http://cdmagurus.com/article/3130254/mobile/supreme-court-wrestles-with-size-of-damages-for-apple-design-patents.html#jump)
More... (http://www.pcworld.com/article/3130254/mobile/supreme-court-wrestles-with-size-of-damages-for-apple-design-patents.html#tk.rss_all)
Questioning lawyers for the two companies, the justices repeatedly referred to a law (http://www.scotusblog.com/2016/10/argument-preview-justices-to-consider-billion-dollar-verdict-for-samsungs-infringement-of-the-design-of-apples-iphone/) that instructs courts to award patent damages based on the total profit from the infringing device, instead of from just the infringing pieces of the device.
The total-profit rule-for design patents may work for simple products, but not for complex ones like smartphones, Justice Stephen Breyer said. "For wallpaper, you get the whole thing," he said, according to Fortune.com (http://fortune.com/2016/10/11/apple-samsung-scotus/). "A Rolls-Royce with the thing on the hood? No, no, no you don’t get profits on the whole car."
To read this article in full or to leave a comment, please click here (http://cdmagurus.com/article/3130254/mobile/supreme-court-wrestles-with-size-of-damages-for-apple-design-patents.html#jump)
More... (http://www.pcworld.com/article/3130254/mobile/supreme-court-wrestles-with-size-of-damages-for-apple-design-patents.html#tk.rss_all)